In chapter 11, Bernoff and Li discuss the many
benefits of creating an internal community for your company. Through the cases
of Best Buy and Intel, they demonstrate the many positive of such an action.
Best buy was able to listen, talk, energize, support and embrace all of their
community- especially the active ones. This chapter makes me think of Clark University
attempts to engage the ground well- and especially the fact that Clark is not
doing such a great job.
At Clark, one of
the major ways that an internal community is created is with all the Facebook
groups – from class specific ones “Class of 2013”, “Class of 2014” to major
specific “Clark Political Science major”, to student clubs on “Clark Hillel”. In
these Facebook groups, Clarkies connect with other Clarkias on a wide variety
of topics, publish their events, and even post announcements for housing opportunities
r off jobs. However, despite the well-meaning aspect of these Facebook groups,
these Facebook group are exclusively catered to students, by students- there is
no administration or executive outpost. So, even if the students are
appreciative of these different Facebook groups and enjoy being able to talk to
each other in a virtual manner, the administration is not getting any feedback
or demonstrating any response.
An example of the variety of Clark Facebook groups
There are so
many opportunities that Clark is faced with that the administration could utilize
this already exciting network. Most recently, Clark changed its policy from a
need blind to a need aware. This resonated sharply with the Clarkes, who
sharply responded in the way that Clarkies know how – a online petition, a Facebook
group and a protest in front of the administration building. In response to
this energy, Clark did not respond in an innovate way or even virtual way.
Instead of posting straight to Facebook, they held a meeting. This meeting,
held in the middle of the day, was mostly attended by administration and furious
parents- but Clarkies presence was scant. This demonstrates the difference in
how the administration and the Clarkies communicate. Even today, Clarkies are
still mad; which highlights Bernoff belief that “without management active
participation, your efforts will fail”.
Clarkies wrote about it in the Scarlet
However, some
staff are willing to participate in this groundswell. Most recently for international
happy day, a Clark student produced a video entitled “Clark University “”happy.
In this video you see a variety of Clark student dancing and lip-syncing to the
popular song, Happy Day by Pharell. This video is cute, it is fun. It is also staffed
with a couple of staff members that are willing to “let loose” for the benefit
of the community. The participation of the staff and administration serves to humane
them in the eyes of other Clark students. However, there is only so much good
this video can do.
Clark should really push for an administration that will engage with the internal community of the school. Students need to feel like their administration is listening to them.
ExxonMobil began in 1859, when Colonel Edwin Drake drilled an oil well in Titusville,
Pennsylvania.
The Drake Well was the first in the world to be drilled for the sole purpose of finding oil, needed to satisfy a growing demand as a consequence of the industrial revolution.
Since then, Exxon Mobil grew from a regional marketer of kerosene into a flourishing corporation
With 37 oil refineries in 21 countries constituting combined daily refining capacities of 6.3 million barrels, ExxonMobil is the largest publicly traded petroleum and petrochemical enterprise in the world.
ExxonMobil is one of the largest and most profitable
companies in the world. In May, ExxonMobil was first in the Fortune 500, vastly outdoing its competitions and other sizable corporations such as Ford, Chevron , Microsoft and Apple.
ExxonMobil’s has a vast amount and great variety of
share and stakeholders. Their website identifies 5 categories of stakeholders: the
governments of the 47 countries in which they have operations, its estimated
2.5 million individuals and more than 2,000 institutions shareholders
(including the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation ), its estimated 160,000
suppliers of goods and services, and its nearly 77, 000 employees in 67
countries around the world.
II.Current Online Presence
When I first goggled « Exxon mobile and social
media », the first result was a Forbes article called “Exxon Mobil has apathetic website. Why?” The authors go on to examine the different social media
tools that the corporations have and has not tapped into. The authors conclude
by saying that the corporate websites are tricky since the audience of these
website are generally job searchers, analysts and journals which are three
different types of people, with different level of social media and virtual engagement.
Before accepting
this article at face value, it is important to independently analyzes qualitatively
the reality of Exxon Mobile social media. Website
The cooperation
has a website accessible at http://corporate.exxonmobil.com. The website interface is smooth, and contains
information on the company for journalists and investors, as well as a career plateform
Youtube
Since April 2006,
Exxon Mobil has been active on YouTube and the channel has 7000
subscribers and over 1236130 views. In addition to their offical page, they
have also partnered with three subsidiary YouTube pages –OfficialMobil1, Official
Mobil and mobile industries that have 5K, 74 and 128 subscribers respecting
They have 54 videos
on their page. Some of them are 30 second clips that seek to demonstrate how
cutting edge and advance the company is.
For example, this video explains how ExxonMobil is providing natural gas security to Western Europe.
The latest video,
posted 2 months ago, is another 30 second clips that highlights Exxon investment
in energy efficient. This clip has over 3,000,000 views.
Finally, Exxon has
also posted clips that highlight their charitable work in the world, such as
the national you teach programs. This is a longer clip (2:00) and highlights
the incredible financial contributes that Exxon partakes in giving nonprofits
and SETM initiatives.
Since ExxonMobil is
an international cooperation with over 100 years of experience in the Middle
East and North African region, it is understandable that some of the YouTube videos
are not going to be in the English language, such as the video below;
Thus, Exxon knows
how to use their YouTube page. However, what is common about all of these
videos and clips is that line at the bottom of the screen:
The official
channel of the company has videos highlighting the real time updates of the
company, employee videos, advertisement campaigns, and videos from the top
management and leadership discussing various issues regarding the company and
its products, environment issues, challenges and the company efforts. Blog
Another major
effort of Exxon Mobil is its Perspectives blog which is run by Ken
Cohen, ExxonMobil's vice president of public and government affairs.
The blog talks about company's views on the issues, policies,
technologies and trends that are shaping the energy industry and Ken Cohen
talks about ideas and actions from industry, governments, researchers and many
others that affect the world of energy. The blog was started in
November 2011 and it is widely followed and read by many people online
Again though, Ken
Cohen is the only contributor to the blog. There is no place for contributors
or comments. It is just his view and his contribution. Twitter:
Exxon Mobil has an official twitter account
with about 26,000 followers and more than 1000 tweets. However, when looking
over the various tweets one sees that they are only focused on providing news about the company and direction
towards the Perspectives blogs.
Instagram
Their Instagram
page is abysmal. With only 34 followers and one posts, it looks like the
attempt to have an Instagram page was abandoned.
Who did not have to sit through
the school assembly and listen to the adults tell you about the dangers of
smoking? “Do not smoke” they say in a monotone voice and you twitch and turn,
hiding your yawn under your sweatshirt.
With cellphones and tablets galore, it is almost impossible to get teenagers attention anymore...
Let's be honest...
We are all Calvin sometimes...
Teenagers are a difficult audience to successfully market to. They do not want
to hear adults tell them what to do. They do not want to be spoken down to. They
do not react or respond to the traditional public service announcement. To
reach teenagers, you need to think like a teenager and talk "straight to them”. The Food and Drug Administration understand that, and their latest PSA campaign effectively ties directly into what our class is all about--effectively taping into the Groundswell by speaking directly to the consumers.
They most recent campaign is called “The Real Cost” and was launched nationally on February 11, 2014 across
multiple media platforms including TV, radio, print, and online. The campaign
will continue to air in more than 200 markets across the country for at least
one year
This ad series
directly target teenagers by addressing their desire to ;
-Take care of their physical appearances
In these ad, the teenagers need to give up their teeth and nice skin in order to smoke.
-
Be independent and notbullied
oIn this
ad, we have the personification of the cigarette as a bully. When you put the
cigarette as a bully (taking your money, telling you to go outside), you make
the teenager look like the victim of a bully- a position that no teenager wants
to be in.
In this example, the
FDA is using the viral videos to “punch
through the noise (p.124)”. Traditional advertising, or the typical
parental speech of “just say no”, is not cutting it anymore. By reaching out
and touching the teenager on what they care about, the ad is a lot more
effective.
However, this add is not only unique because of the content, but also because of the way it was distributed. Instead of pamphlets or brochures, these ads can be found on Youtube and on Hulu- websites that generate a lot of traffic (by mostly teenagers).On YouTube, these ads have been seen by over 500,000 times, which is impressive. On hulu, these ads can be found
FDA's goal is to keep “The Real Cost” campaign
authentic through a peer-to-peer approach. Thus, “The Real Cost” campaign
website (www.therealcost.gov8) and social channels are intended for
teens.
They are going viral with this content. As can be seen with
This ad campaign is fascinating and hopefully will bear fruits since teenage smoking is a great public health issue.
In the book Groundswell, the authors make
two very interesting points:
·Listen
to your consumers
·React
to the public and individual posts
McDonald's is an organization that took Groundswell, advice to heart during their rebranding of the Chicken McNugget.
A couple of years ago, McDonals was accused of putting pink goo (otherwise known as pink slime) in their food. The picture below went viral and appeared on all the different social media outlets.
The rallying of the online community bore its ground and was effective. Indeed, a mere nine days into the petition (when it reached over 200,000 signatures), USDA announced that starting in the fall of 2012 it will offer school districts a choice of beef either with LFTB or without the filler.
Instead of sitting on their hands and assuming that the crisis will blow over, McDonald responded to this crisis by creating and maintaining their own online community. Why? In my opinion, the company wanted to control the overall mood of their customers. While I think that there will always be customers for McDonald low cost, low quality products, why risk having negative publicity? As the book says, you do not control your brand, your customers do.
With the subtitle " Our food. Your questions", the website tries to improve their brand by speaking with their customers (as opposed to yelling at them or even worse, ignoring them)
For
example, (going back to the pink goo) Armand from Alberta asks about the pink goo in the chicken nugget . McDonald's responded via a Youtube video.
This YouTube video is a great example of a effective way that McDonald invalidates the accusation of pink goop in their food. By seeing the process from beginning to the end, the viewer can not help but be convinced of the validity of their position .
and on their website;
Notice the
Facebook, Twitter, and Google+ opportunities at the bottom of the answer.
I am sure McDonald
would love it you posted this answer on your own social media page… generating
free advertisement and increase their reach into your social network. In this
interactive website, McDonald effective put in places an online community that
they can respond to (read ..lie to)in case of a crisis.
Since I can remember, I have always had a diary. It is
not a journal, I do not write in it daily or on a regular basis. I write in it
when “big” things in my life occur- grades are posted, friends are lost and
gained, trips are taken, secrets are received, fights occur and yelling
happens. I often joke with friends that if ever the diary landed into the hands
of a stranger, that stranger would think that I was an emotional and dramatic wreck
who is solely focused on grades and boys. The beauty of this diary is that it
is written evidence of the changes that have occurred in my lifetime- that is the
changes that I think is necessary to write down. Getting them down on paper
helps get them out of my brain.
Recently, I learned that one of friends was violently
raped. However, I was not told in the traditional manner- word of mouth, phone
call, letter or email. She blogged about her experience. On a traditional
Saturday afternoon, what starts like a regular blog posting quickly turned into
a confession. Instead of telling people of her experience in a common way, she
used her greatest strength, he words as her weapon and her shield.
What pushes a person to blog about a traumatic
experience? What is that person looking for when she is giving the world access
to her most private and intimate thoughts?
By posting about
her experience, she is trying to empower other women who went through similar
experiences and are ashamed about it. The plethora of traditional advertisement
like the posters below or the video, can only reach so many people and are
limited in their effectiveness.
In digital
media, the reach of one blog post can go very far.
According to her
blog post:
“I'm putting this out there
because when I was raped I remember thinking that no, Law and Order SVU does
not prepare you for this sort of situation. And no, not everyone is kind or
supportive. I know there are people who will read this and judge me for it, and
I'm ready for that. I was a strong character to begin with, and this whole
ordeal has only built me up with more courage to speak out about injustice. If
someone reading this is a rape victim I hope my late night post gives you some
comfort. There is so much isolation that comes with this type of trauma. I hope
you know that you can get through it.”
In blogging,
people who do not know you are reading and reacting to your posts such as Jennifer
Warren who writes that;
“Wow, your story was extremely moving. I am sorry that
all of this happened to you and you had to endure that kind of pain and
injustice. I do not know you, but I know you did not deserve to be raped-no one
deserves that. I am happy that you seem to be trying to find the positive in
your life and inspire other people. Best of luck to you at Columbia.”
When it is a
victim blogging about her experience, the message is so much more powerful. You feel
connected, you feel empathy, you feel outrage at the injustice committed.There is nothing more effective than having that
personal touch.
The rise in
homemade movies surrounding do not ask, do not tell and gay military members
also demonstrates the tremendous influence that digital media has on
interpersonal experience. After the repeal of DADT, a plethora of homemade YouTube began sprouting up about military
members coming out of the closet in the most public way possible.
On Sep
19, 2011, a military man calls his father in Alabama and for the first time,
LIVE, tell him he is gay. The raw emotions in this YouTube clip makes the
viewer feel connected to the boy “ my heart is racing like crazy” “It is 2 in
the morning, I am in Germany, I did not sleep all night” “ he breathes out as
the phone rings. “Can I tell you something”“ Will you love me . You will always
love me ? Dad I am gay. The father replies “Ok” “Ok”- “I still love you son. It
does not change our relationship.”
This video has been seen over 7,000,000
times.
If one searches
“gay military men coming out”, one finds over 45,000 results
.
Here again, we
have a person who uses digital media as a way to empower other. With YouTube,
the military man knew that others would watch his movie- and perhaps be
empowered to come out as well. In Izzies post, she ends on a rallying cry to
empowering cry to other rape victims.
In this first 6
chapters, authors Josh Bernoff and Charlene Li discusses a variety of
groundswell tools and their implication for traditional institutions. One of
the groundswell tools identified are forums,
ratings and reviews which allow customers to publicly comment on their
purchases and activities. Due to the
rise of digital media, everyone is sharing, tweeting, pinning and posting about
their newest purchase, latest trip and best recipe. Online brand reputation is
more and more linked to ratings posted rather than the millions of dollars that
companies throw at the brand in the form of advertisement.
Below is evidence of
such a difference.
In these two images, we clearly see the difference
between community branding and institutional branding. Nike wants to highlight
their strong athletic ties, the community wants to highlight Nike HR abuse and
other “sucky” actions.
The stark difference between these two images
highlight the need for traditional institutional to understand that they no
longer control their own brand, the customers and reviews do. Even those
who have never consumed, but take the time to critic and post, can be more
influential that all the ads that companies might make.
Trip Advisor and Yelp
are two platforms that thrive on user-generated content. They are popular
online travel guidewhere customers
review and give ratings to different places to eat, sleep and visit around the
world. The interface is simple to use and customers are free to praise or
critic the retailer.
So I ask... Are these better than published review from a expert reviews ? and if so why?
According to my
sister, yes since they are more genuine by presenting the overall “average”
experience:
“I am not getting
special treatment when I am going to the restaurant, so why should the
reviewer? I am an average customer, so I want to see what the ‘average Joe’ has
to say”.
Also, she adds that
Yelp is a great tool to see aggregated data : "In one second, I can see the
reviews from not only those who had a good or a bad experience, but also those
who just went for dessert, happy hour or with kids”.
This variety of online
user generated content enables the publication of negative and positive ads. My
family went to Colorado last summer, and were not thrilled with the suggestions
of where to sleep. In response, we posted our criticisms…. and got a response
from the management straight away on the website.
Comments from mother and sister;
The reply from the
rental company, although somewhat generic, is still symbolic and demonstrates
that they understand the need to listen, and respond to negative critics.
For
Long Peak , while our reviews were more on
the critical side, others were quite positive.
This variety of opinions is much more realistic that if all you heard was negative or positive Having a community discuss your product, is similar to being in a coffee shop with friends, all discussing the latest movie or book. Online, everyone’s opinion matters.
Everyone is right and everyone is wrong
People
are influenced when people in their entourage are recommending good books or
appliances. They do not want to hear from someone who is PAID to tell them how
good something is, but rather want to
hear from their friends the “nitty and gritty”truth.
Customer
reviews are also important for small businesses that do not benefit from a large presence in the traditional advertising word. My parents just bought a
apartment to rent out to tourist. Since there are a
variety of other vacation rentals, consumer reviews can be the deciding factor for potential customers.
The apartment
is on Yelp. Despite a rating of 5 stars, there is only one posted review… This
can make potential customers not trust the review as much had there been multiple.
Despite
the fact that we have tenants, there is a difference between those who read and
those who write. This is refered to as the "difference between the
spectators and the critics". For this reason, we have high average rating from a
few number of reviews.
On
Trip Advisor, we are doing a little better. We have a rating of 5/5 with 11
reviews.
A final interesting point about customer’s reviews is that they exist in both print and digital media.However, most of the reviews are still in the print form. Rarely, if at all, do you find customer review in the form of a homemade movie. There are some YouTube videos that show consumers talking about a product, such as the clip below about Acai Cleanse Acai Berry Detox below, however I do not think that this type of review is effective as a written post.
According to my sister, “the problem with video is that you
are totally dependent on what they say”. When I read reviews, “I get to control
what I read, or in other words you chose how much information you get...when you have
written reviews, you quickly get the message ‘in one sec’.
So even if Youtube videos are more "personal" because you see the critique, written word enables us to to see the information that we need and move on. For this reason, I ask;
-Is the written word still the most powerful word of all?